Skip to main content

One Reason Why Condo Buyers Pay More to Get their Mortgages

I helped some clients sell their condo apartment yesterday. As we sat at the closing table, the topic of conversation turned to the recent pricing increases and still tighter lending standards that were recently implemented for condo purchase money mortgage loans. The loan officer, real estate agents, and buyer were all commiserating & railing against the higher cost as being pointless and painful.

Then, on my return to the office, I saw an email from Kathleen Robson, a loan officer at Wintrust, that helped remind me why the lenders are still being so cautious.

She described 2 recent files she had worked on: The one involved a developer apparently had been collecting money from unit owners but then suddenly left town (presumably to a country with no extradition) and no one was left to run the condo association. The other involved a developer that simply was not collecting assessments from the owners of sold units (or paying assessments on the unsold units) but may have lied on paperwork submitted to the lender to say that he was.

No lender wants to loan money against a Condominium that is not operating honestly (or not at all). No Buyer wants to own in this scenario either. If the association does not have funds on hand, it cannot pay for say... water, electricity, insurance, property taxes or any of the other common expenses. If there is no management, there is no forum to address problems or manage the property.

Kathleen asked if there is any way to verify, independently, whether or not a developer - controlled condo is operational. There is none. The developers handling of assessments is just one of many risks involved in a purchase transaction. Lenders see the risks the same way as I do, (and we both charge clients more because of those risks)

A large part of any Chicago area real estate lawyer's practice involves the purchase and sale of condominiums, at least mine does. A large portion of my condominium practice involves purchases and sales of newly-built or newly converted condominiums.

I've been seeing these scenarios too for the last couple of years. Of all the condo purchase opportunities out there in the world right now the riskiest (to me, anyway) are:
  • conversion projects built since 2006,
  • by small and medium sized developers,
  • with fewer than 70-75% of the units sold
I routinely URGE clients to steer clear of these. New construction condos of similar provenance to be nearly as dangerous.

In Illinois, a developer is required to turn over control within 60 days of (the earlier of) closing 75% of the project or within 3 years of recording the Declaration. Once they turn-over, the unit owners run the show themselves, and there is much less risk of financial malfeasance. But until the turn-over? There's the danger zone.

When the markets are hot, turnovers happen pretty quickly. In the doldrums, Developers have been holding on to many unsold units and are retaining control of associations for much, much longer. Very few of them have the sort of financial "transparency" that allows for owners - or prospective buyers - to get much comfort.

We simply can't stop unscrupulous developers form lying on questionnaires or financial statements, but we can be more exacting in our due diligence as we review contracts prior to closing. I for one have begun asking developer-attorneys to prove that assessments will be paid into a segregated, single-purpose bank account established for the association's funds alone - as an additional provision in the purchase contract. I am also asking for photo-copies of bank statements to support the existence (and use) of the account.

Even then, no one can force the developer who is collecting assessments checks to actually deposit them after a closing.

The good news here is that, at this point, the "bad guys" are doing this more out of
desperation than greed. they are not making sales so they are not making any money. if this is all that is left to them, they must be pretty desperate. the small-time, under-capitalized developers are dying off. before too long we will be rid of them.


Popular posts from this blog

The Equifax data breach and you — 6 steps to take now

Identity thieves hit a major credit reporting agency—hard. Millions of consumers’ confidential identity information has been compromised.

Equifax, one of the big three credit reporting agencies announced that a massive security breach took place earlier this year. Offenders accessed data sets of 143 million US consumers.

What to do when drones fly near your home

Imagine a quiet evening on the deck of your new home when—out of nowhere—a noisy drone begins hovering around your property, almost certainly snapping photos or video. It’s like Space Invaders meets Gladys Kravitz. So what do you do?

Help! My Neighbor’s Old Tree is Growing Over my Roof

Let’s say about 100 years ago, a family planted an oak tree on the edge of their property. Over generations it’s grown into a magnificent tree that provides summer shade, autumn color and a swing for the neighborhood kids. You probably even liked the tree when you bought the house next door to it.

But today, its root system is invading your basement, its acorns bombard your yard and its huge limbs loom threateningly over your roof. By law, can you cut it down? Trim it? Turn it into a boat?