Skip to main content

The buyer’s guide to homeowners insurance

By Michael H. Wasserman
It’s exciting to find a home to buy and have a signed contract in hand. This is when most home buyers start thinking about the fun stuff, like remodeling and decorating. Yet many forget one important step: securing homeowners insurance—which could derail the closing.

Unlike auto or renters insurance, securing homeowners insurance takes time. It is best to get started just after your real estate contract has been accepted—and well before you move in. Yet, most folks put this important step off, which could mess with the closing—especially if there’s a mortgage. So, we thought we’d give you the lowdown on getting homeowners insurance.


Choosing a competent and experienced agent is a good start. We talked to State Farm Agent Dave Frederickson in Edgewater, Chicago. We peppered him with questions and he gave us loads of information to share with our buyers. Here’s what we learned.

Q. When is the best time for a home buyer to look for home owner’s insurance?
A. As soon as your contract is signed. It’s better to have this in place earlier than later. Some banks use the policy information to finalize the mortgage. Further, many contracts require the buyer to confirm the property’s insurability within a week of signing the contract.

Q. Why should a buyer start looking for home owners insurance so early?
Underwriters need time to review all of the information. If they see anything that needs repair or is out of code, they might not approve the policy—or ask for repairs or estimates for repairs, which also take time to complete. 

If a policy is approved but requires repairs, the underwriters will require proof that the repairs were complete in order for the insurance policy to remain in place.

Q. What happens if a buyer waits to get homeowners insurance at the last minute?
Procrastination could delay the closing, as mortgage lenders won’t close on an uninsured property.

Q. What kind of information will the insurance company need?
A. Essentially, the underwriters need to determine the costs of replacing or rebuilding the home (not just the cost to buy it). To determine that amount, buyers generally need to provide: 
• Amount of the final offer
• Contact info for lender or bank 
• Contact info for the buyer’s attorney
• Copy of the mortgagee clause 
• Copy of the appraisal 
• Photos of the home

A buyer should also consider the replacement cost of their belongings—we’ll get to that in a minute.

What type of insurance do mortgage lenders require?
For single-family homes, lenders require a basic HO3 policy or a HO5 policy, which offers more coverage than an HO3. For condominiums, lenders require an HO6 policy.

Keep in mind, each insurance company has standard homeowners’ policies, but each company offers slightly different coverage. It’s important for homebuyers to take the time to compare a few different offerings. 

The cheapest policy might not be the best value. As Dave likes to say,
“The insurance you choose doesn’t matter, until it does.”

Q. What does that type of insurance cover?
All policies provide a level of coverage for the dwelling, but it varies for single-family homes and condominiums.  

Single family home HO3s and HO5s provide coverage for:
• Dwelling
• Dwelling extension, like a garage
• Contents/belongings*
• Additional living expenses in case of an event
• Various levels of liability for accidents 

Condominium insurance works differently.
The association should have a master policy, which will protect the exterior building. It may cover the building and each unit’s walls, or only the building outside the unit’s walls. Each association is different, sure to check the bylaws.

Condominium HO6s provide coverage for:
• Contents/belongings*
• Additional living expenses in case of an event
• Various levels of liability for accidents 

Q. How can a buyer determine if they need additional coverage for their belongings? 
A. Before you talk to your agent, take a look at your belongings and consider how much it would be to replace them. State Farm has some pointers for making a home inventory.

In general, buyers might need extra coverage if the home has high-end appliances, if they own expensive jewelry or items, or if the bank says you don’t have enough coverage. This is a good thing to ask your insurance agent.

Q. What else isn’t covered with basic homeowners insurance?
A. Most policies don’t cover extraordinary events, like floods (flood insurance would be purchased via FEMA), earthquakes, or sewer back-ups (a common Chicago-area occurrence).

Q. Wait, did you say earthquakes? 
A. Yes. Most people don’t realize that there’s an active seismic zone in Southern Illinois, the New Madrid Fault line. But the further you are from the fault line, the cheaper the coverage cost of earthquake insurance.

Q. What are some money-saving tips for homeowners insurance?
A. There are a few ways, including: 
• Bundling homeowners with auto insurance. 
• Getting a security system. 
• Choosing a high deductible. 
• Paying out-of-pocket for small repairs (below deductible amount) 

Also, if you’ve been with your insurance company for a long time, you might get a loyalty credit. At State Farm, if you have another policy (say renters), they may offer a loyalty credit that transfers to the next policy. 

Q. Can a buyer simply transfer an existing homeowners policy to a new home?
A. No, the policy has to be re-written.

Q. In Illinois, do homeowners need to use an in-state insurance broker/agent?
A. Yes. But if the home is close to a state line, buyers can find an agent that is licensed in both states (like Indiana/Illinois or Wisconsin/Illinois), which could be helpful if the buyer is moving (or might move) across the border. 

Q. What if the home will be vacant for a few months after closing?  
A. Some buyers don’t plan to move in right away. If this is the case, the buyer will need to work closely with their agent. It is harder to insure a property if it’s not occupied—many companies will decline insuring it. But it’s not impossible. For example, if they plan to renovate before moving in, they’ll need to provide a timeline and work order to obtain insurance. 

Q. Is there anything else a buyer should know about buying homeowners insurance? 
A. Research the insurance carrier. The cheapest insurance, might not be the best value in the long run. Your home is a giant investment, it’s smart for buyer to have a good agent and company to turn to for help.

Thanks to Dave Frederickson of State Farm for his helpful information and time. If you’d like to pepper Dave with your own questions, you can email him at David@davidfred.com

If you have any questions about your real estate transaction for our firm, find us at mhwasserman.com.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

FHA Loans and Condo Sales - Is Relief on the Way?

By all outward appearances, state government in Illinois has ground to a complete halt, with all eyes focused on the Governor's "problem" and all the related fal - der -rah. Its hardly business as usual in Springfield, but not everything has ground to a halt. Several new bills have been introduced this week. That is not to say that they will be of benefit to we the people. Nonetheless, the cogs and gears are turning, and we are hoping for the best. One such proposal comes from Rep. LaShawn Ford of Chicago's west side, who is himself a real estate broker and entrepreneur . He is the author of House Bill 155 , introduced & referred to the Rules Committee Wednesday. It seeks to address one of the most common problems I am seeing in condominium resale transactions these days; the tension between many Declarations of Condominium and FHA loan guidelines. Many Condo Declarations provide Associations with a "right of first refusal," which basically allows t

So.... about the blawg

Nov. 2022 Hello Dear Reader. I started blogging on this site 15 years ago.  Crazy right? May or may not Chicago's longest-running blog about real estate law. I think so, but who knows, Whether it is or isn't doesn't, of course, really matter.   Either way, it's been a blast.  But things change. We've pulled up the tent stakes here and are relocated on other platforms. Want to follow along? Join us on the mothership I'm also writing on LinkedIn Thanks for everything.

PLM Title Shuttered

Title insurance is a critically important part of any real estate transaction; or at least it should be. The title company guaranties the "quality" of an owners interest in the property - that there aren't any (unknown) liens or defects. No buyer that I work for will purchase a property without it. Title insurance is only as good as the insurer. We want to know that the insurance company, like the Rock of Gibraltar , will always be there. We want to sleep easy at night, knowing that the client is protected. That said, it was a bit distressing to see that PLM Title Company shut its doors, without any forewarning last week. Worse still, this morning's news is that there is a criminal investigation underway - and that we do not yet know why. Old timers like me shudder with memories of the great Intercounty Title debacle five years ago. Here's to hoping that this one is nothing like that one. Set aside the problems involved trying to make a claim against a defun